[KP]

Just to be clear, I'm not taking either side of this escalating debate. Actually, IMO, this is a really good debate, especially getting ready for the point/counterpoint.

I have two comments to make, and both pertain to how the Angels handled similar situations you pointed out, Avery.

1. Chone Figgins doesn't care where he plays. He just wants to play. And, his ability dictates that he play...somewhere. He has said many times that he doesn't care where he plays. He just comes to the ballpark ready to play, checks the lineup and goes out and performs. So, I think the "un-nerving" comment is a bit unjustified if you have the proper mental makeup and accept your role. He plays all over the field and hits all throughout the lineup, depending on injuries and such.

2. The Angels cut ties with Guillen in the midst of a playoff race. He has extremely productive all year and should have even made the All-Star team last year. However, his attitude was counterproductive. Chemistry is a very underrated commoditiy in sports, IMO. Now, one could say that it was coincidence that the A's decided to suck around the same time the Angels suspended Guillen. Nonetheless, Guillen was a major part of the offense and outfield defense. A major part. All I'm saying here is that there may be an instance where Graves' attitude was detrimental to the team. Sure, the Reds aren't winning right now. But, maybe management wants to foster a certain type of atmosphere and Graves' behavior didn't translate.

Just my two cents....